Quantcast The Mac Weekly
College Media Network

Current Issue:

MCSG considers plan to restructure textbook prices

Under proposal, sticker price would rise by about $585 to finance discounts at bookstore

By: Kaia Arthur, Staff Writer

Issue date: 11/2/07 Section: News
Amid student complaints of unreasonable textbook prices, students, professors and administrators are considering a proposal that would draw from an increase in tuition dollars and level book costs for students.
Media Credit: Aaron Brown
Amid student complaints of unreasonable textbook prices, students, professors and administrators are considering a proposal that would draw from an increase in tuition dollars and level book costs for students.

Responding to rising textbook costs and a number of student complaints, the Macalester College Student Government this semester has begun to discuss a potential plan to lower textbook prices with professors and administrators. The proposal would cause tuition costs for students who do not receive financial aid to rise by about $585, which would go toward subsidizing textbook costs for all students.

In a recent MCSG survey of 400 students, a quarter said they had encountered difficulties in purchasing textbooks due to financial constraints and a third said they are "still worried about it." Sixty percent replied that they often did not have their books within a few days after the beginning of class. Almost 30 percent of the surveyed students said that, on at least one occasion, they did not buy a required book at all.

"There's an assumption that students are having to make a choice and are forgoing textbooks," Dean of Students Jim Hoppe said.

Academic Affairs Commission chair Alison Tray '09 approached Mathematics professor Danny Kaplan to discuss methods for making textbooks more accessible to students.

Tray and Kaplan, who served on the Minnesota legislature's Textbook Advisory Task Force, focused primarily on presenting a plan that would make books immediately available to students, regardless of their financial situation.

"Professor Kaplan had this idea that works like a medical insurance policy," Tray said. "You make an initial payment and then just have to pay the co-pay for actual services."

The proposal has not appeared in formal print, and has only taken form in discussions. The administration, Hoppe said, is now considering the issue, but has not moved past that initial phase of deliberation.

According to Kaplan and Tray, some students on need-based financial aid currently receive $900 in addition to their grant money to pay for supplies and textbooks. Under the plan, students who receive the $900 grant would receive 65 percent less to offset a corresponding tuition increase of $585 for students who do not receive financial aid.
Page 1 of 2 next >

Article Tools

Viewing Comments 1 - 3 of 3

Brandon

posted 11/02/07 @ 4:00 PM CST

I agree that textbook prices are a problem. But I think we can come up with a better solution than instituting a medical-insurance-type plan.

A medical-insurance-type plan would aggravate the problem by reducing the incentive to shop around and seek the lowest possible prices. (Continued…)

Michael Barnes

posted 11/03/07 @ 10:54 AM CST

This plan seems unnecessarily complicated.

At first I was sure there must be an error, and that everyone's tuition would increase by $500+, and that only people NOT on financial aid would pay the full cost, simply because people on financial aid never pay the full cost of their tuition. (Continued…)

Jack

posted 11/09/07 @ 12:46 PM CST

Great! We'll dupe more people into using the bookstore with no net savings for, gosh, anyone.

This plan isn't even worth engaging on its own terms. (Continued…)

Post a Comment

  • NOTE: Email address will not be published

Type your comment below (html not allowed)

  I understand posting spam or other comments that are unrelated to this article will cause my comment to be flagged for deletion and possibly cause my IP address to be permanently banned from this server.

Advertisement

Poll

How should Macalester cover its losses in the financial crisis?
Submit Vote

View Results

Advertisement